[RESOLVED] Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2014 3:01 pm
... and XHR and window.setTimeout() and dev tools, again! Same test cases as when Fx 27 broke them a month ago. Tested with NS 2.6.8.18rc1.
InformAction Forums
NoScripters and WebSec nerds of all lands, unite!
https://forums.informaction.com/
[RESOLVED] Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Page 1 of 1
Re: Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2014 3:18 pm
Is it that it doesn't work in a New Tab, but will once a page has first loaded?
Re: Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2014 3:52 pm
Same as last time. Load a page, add an event listener in a bookmarklet or Scratchpad. Listener won't fire unless scripts are enabled for that domain.
Re: Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2014 4:05 pm
Confirmed in Gecko 28 with this testcase as URL bar typed/pasted JS:
Also doesn't work from the Web Console.
Gecko 29 (SeaMonkey Aurora 20140317013001) doesn't seem affected.
Code: Select all
javascript:document.body.addEventListener("click", function(){alert("You clicked!");},false);void(0);Gecko 29 (SeaMonkey Aurora 20140317013001) doesn't seem affected.
Re: Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2014 8:29 pm
( Code: ... )
Are you sure that's correct?
Are you sure that's correct?
Re: Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2014 10:12 pm
Yes, why?
Re: Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Posted: Fri Mar 21, 2014 10:47 pm
Well, at first I wasn't making it work.
And just now I did, accidentally.
But I do show that it works in FF28.
And SeaMonkey 2.26a2, Aurora.
With SeaMonkey you get a beep.
With FF, not.
It does not work on a about:newtab, about: ... type of "page", but maybe that's to be expected.
Oh, wait... FF had NoScript 2.6.8.11rc4 in it...
But I still see it working in FF28 with NoScript 2.6.8.18rc1.
And just now I did, accidentally.
But I do show that it works in FF28.
And SeaMonkey 2.26a2, Aurora.
With SeaMonkey you get a beep.
With FF, not.
It does not work on a about:newtab, about: ... type of "page", but maybe that's to be expected.
Oh, wait... FF had NoScript 2.6.8.11rc4 in it...
But I still see it working in FF28 with NoScript 2.6.8.18rc1.
Re: Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Posted: Sat Mar 22, 2014 1:03 am
Heh, I didn't test Fx at all for reasons you can guess... 
I was testing on a completely script-forbidden http page.
It never worked for me with any SeaMonkey on about: pages, even with scripts allowed and/or running the code from the Web Console instead of through NS, so I guess that is expected.
On the script-disabled http page, SeaMonkey 2.25 didn't fire the event listener at all, not even after running the test code from the Web Console or trying a new profile with only NoScript added (but no Web Console there...), so I would guess this is more likely a Gecko 28-specific bug than a NoScript bug or extension conflict.
@therube, what did you do that made it work, and on what page??
I was testing on a completely script-forbidden http page.
It never worked for me with any SeaMonkey on about: pages, even with scripts allowed and/or running the code from the Web Console instead of through NS, so I guess that is expected.
On the script-disabled http page, SeaMonkey 2.25 didn't fire the event listener at all, not even after running the test code from the Web Console or trying a new profile with only NoScript added (but no Web Console there...), so I would guess this is more likely a Gecko 28-specific bug than a NoScript bug or extension conflict.
@therube, what did you do that made it work, and on what page??
Re: Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Posted: Sun Mar 23, 2014 12:40 pm
Please check latest development build 2.6.8.18rc2, thanks.
Re: Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Posted: Sun Mar 23, 2014 7:51 pm
Seems fixed here, both URL bar JS and the Web Console work properly with my testcase in Gecko 28 now. Thanks a lot!
Re: [RESOLVED] Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Posted: Mon Mar 24, 2014 8:16 pm
I agree.
window.setTimeout/Interval() remain unavailable on script-disabled sites, but then I suspect that was already the case after last month's Firefox changes and it's not a very serious loss anyway.
Thanks Giorgio.
window.setTimeout/Interval() remain unavailable on script-disabled sites, but then I suspect that was already the case after last month's Firefox changes and it's not a very serious loss anyway.
Thanks Giorgio.
Re: [RESOLVED] Fx 28 breaks bookmarklet event listeners
Posted: Mon Mar 24, 2014 10:20 pm
WFM, so it's probably another Gecko 28 bug..porl wrote:window.setTimeout/Interval() remain unavailable on script-disabled sites