alice-dsl.de web form doesn't work

[e80]

Hi,

i'm having problems with this web form: http://www.alice-dsl.de/provider/conten ... 5340174010

With NoScript (v1.9.9.84 [also tried v1.9.9.81], allow scripts globally enabled) and AdBlockPlus (v1.2, Easy List Germany + EasyPrivacy) both enabled, i can't enter anything into the form. If i disable either NoScript or AdBlockPlus, it magically starts working. I am at a loss as to what might be causing this. Any ideas? Can anyone confirm the problem?

[Alan Baxter]

I've loaded your url with a test profile that has no extensions installed at all. I don't see any form. Could you provide more specific directions for reproducing your problem?

[dhouwn]

I guess you have to click "Auswählen" for the particular form to show up.

[Alan Baxter]

Edit 2: I'm able to duplicate the problem reported by the OP, but I'm unable to see why it's happening. Here's what I see:
1) If NoScript is uninstalled, then the form works without having to disable any of the Adblock Plus filters.
2) If NoScript is installed, with default settings, then the form does not work, even if scripts are globally allowed.
3) Even with scripts globally allowed, I have to disable two of the Adblock Plus filters. I don't have to disable these filters if NoScript isn't installed.

Code: Select all

||doubleclick.net/activity$third-party
||doubleclick.net^$~object_subrequest,third-party

There are no NoScript messages in the Error Console. This one's beyond me. Giorgio may have to debug this one.

Edit 1: Oops. It appears that the OP is on to something. I can get the form to work with all of the Adblock Plus filters enabled if I disable NoScript, so some of what follows may be incorrect or incomplete. Investigating...

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I guess you have to click "Auswählen" for the particular form to show up.

Thanks. I can get that form to work with:
NoScript 1.9.9.85 with default settings
Adblock Plus 1.2 with EasyLIst Germany+EasyList + EasyPrivacy
if I Allow alice-dsl.de in NoScript
and disable the following filters in Adblock Plus

Code: Select all

||doubleclick.net/activity$third-party
||doubleclick.net^$~object_subrequest,third-party

That filter was blocking a frame, so make sure you aren't blocking frames in NoScript Options > Embeddings
Report the problem with the filter in the EasyList forum so the list can be fixed. http://forums.lanik.us/viewforum.php?f=64

Hope this helps. Please let us know whether it does.

[Alan Baxter]

Bump. Could you check this report out, Giorgio?

[e80]

The problem is exactly as Alan Baxter describes it. If NoScript and Adblock (config of both as in OP) are running at the same time, the following (and nothing else) has to be whitelisted in Adblock for the form to work:

Code: Select all

http://fls.doubleclick.net/activityi;src=1658458;type=basictra;cat=ausw_lig;ord=1;num=5936761236417.424?

I notified EasyList Germany people of this, but they (understandably) didn't do anything about it because it works with just AdBlock enabled.

I'm sorry if the provided link didn't take you to the form right away. It did for me, but i guess that was because of cookies or something. There is no "Auswählen" there though, i'm clicking on "Jetzt prüfen". You seem to have found a similar form with the same problem in any case though.

[e80]

I have trouble reproducing this issue - using Adblock Plus 1.3a (EasyList+EasyList Germany and Easy), NoScript 1.9.9.90 (scripts globally allowed), Minefield 3.7a6pre that form can be filled out just fine for me.

Edit: Reproduced now - only an issue with Adblock Plus 1.2, not with the current development builds. Also, only Firefox 3.6, not Minefield however.

https://adblockplus.org/forum/viewtopic ... 686#p35685