Oh, OGG! Intended Behavior?

[therube]

Oh, OGG! Intended Behavior?

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/6/61/BiaB(bebop).ogg
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/7/71/BiaB(django).ogg

The music selections play, regardless of any NoScript settings.
The "player" does not show unless wikimedia.com is Allowed.

If wikimedia.com is Not allowed, there is no placeholder.

I think I'm wrong on that part. Placeholder is there, though after initial click, it no longer shows again till you do a Revoke Temporary Permissions (& reload the page).

Are those behaviors expected?

(FF 2 users need not apply .)

[Giorgio Maone]

No, it doesn't play for me (Fx 3.5.3) unless wikimedia.org is allowed.
Maybe a SM-specific thing, downloadig latest SM 2 and checking.

[Giorgio Maone]

Checked on SM 2, same behavior.
I get the placeholder if wikimedia.org is not whitelisted or "Apply to trusted sites" is checked, and when I click the placeholder I get the music always, but the player only if wikimedia.org is whitelisted.
This is expected, because of https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=449358
You'll observe the same effect with NoScript uninstalled and Javascript disabled from browser's built-in preferences.

[Alan Baxter]

I see exactly the same behavior Giorgio describes, and upon careful re-reading, that therube describes on SeaMonkey. Thank you for reminding us of that bug. I think it's come up before.